What's wrong with this picture?

[Walt]

I imagine many of you are familiar with this photo which is probably authentic but which has some mis-identification of the men pictured.

Can you see anything that's unlikely?

[Sixgun]

#3 sure is not Teddy R. plus it looks like he’s wearing a pointy white hat.. Looks like more than a few with the pointy hats. Ahhh, they are just getting ready for some fun later in the day.

[Walt]

I think if the guys are who they're said to be, the date the picture was taken is wrong. Roosevelt would only have been 25 years old in 1883, Butch Cassidy would have been 17. It would be much more believeable if it had been taken 15 or 20 years later.

[JBowen]

I think it would be unlikely that the Erps would be hunting with Butch and Sundance?
Liver Eatin Johnson would probably be too old in 1883?

JBowen

[JimT]

Like Abraham Lincoln said, "90% of the posts on the internet are fake."

[Walt]

Yep, I distictly remember him saying that on the radio.

[Grizz]

Like Abraham Lincoln said, "90% of the posts on the internet are fake."






:lol:

OK I'll take your word for it. BUT I thought I heard him say 93% are fake . . . :)

[Ysabel Kid]

Like Abraham Lincoln said, "90% of the posts on the internet are fake."

[cas]

Morgan Earp died in 1882.

Morgan Erp on the other hand, I have no idea.


(Geo. Parker?)

[Griff]

Morgan Earp died in 1882.
Morgan Erp on the other hand, I have no idea.
(Geo. Parker?)

Spelling is not exactly everyone's long suit.

[1894cfan]

I ain't buying it, TOO danged many notables in one spot in 1883! YMMV

[marlinman93]

Maybe the real question should be what's right with this picture?